Review and Arbitration Process

Authors submitting manuscripts for potential publication in Revista Diá-logos must provide the final version of their work. Upon receipt, the editor will verify that all submission requirements have been met and provide an initial assessment within one month. This preliminary review stage involves the following steps:

  1. The article will be screened using the StrikePlagiarism tool to detect content similarity against existing databases and the use of artificial intelligence. Any submission with a similarity score exceeding 15% compared to previously published work will be rejected. Similarly, any submission with a probability of AI usage exceeding 30% will be rejected.
  2. The submitted text will be assessed for its alignment with the journal’s scope and focus.
  3. The writing quality will be evaluated, focusing on textual coherence, cohesion, appropriateness, and logical flow between paragraphs throughout the article.
  4. The cited sources will be reviewed to ensure they are relevant and up-to-date. Furthermore, the manuscript must adhere to APA formatting guidelines (please refer to the document on APA Standards).

Once the editor has confirmed that these requirements are met, the author will be notified that the double-blind external peer-review process is underway, which will be completed within a maximum of 60 days.

Decisions regarding the acceptance or rejection of an article—made by the editorial team, which includes both national and international reviewers—are based on the work’s relevance, originality, clarity of writing, and its alignment with the journal’s editorial focus.

All submitted material is treated as confidential throughout the evaluation process. In the event of rejection, no reviewer—whether national or international—is permitted to disclose or make public the original manuscript.

The identities of the reviewers are protected, as their anonymity is strictly maintained

Each article will undergo a double-blind external peer review by reviewers from outside the publishing institution, ensuring that the identities of both the authors and the reviewers remain anonymous. If discrepancies arise between the assessments provided by the reviewers, the article will be submitted to a third reviewer for evaluation. The review process will be conducted using the evaluation rubric provided by the journal (you may access the rubric by clicking here).

  1. Articles will be sent to academic experts in the same disciplinary and thematic field. Reviewers will be selected based on their scientific competence and experience in the areas of education, pedagogy, curriculum, and educational innovation.
  2. Reviewers are expected to examine and analyze the scientific, theoretical, and methodological relevance of the assigned article. Furthermore, they must assess the article's alignment with the field of study, the coherence between the academic contribution and the significance of the findings, as well as the currency and appropriateness of the sources cited in the text.
  3. Upon receiving an article, reviewers will have up to one month to complete their review and submit their assessment.
  4. Each article will be sent to two reviewers affiliated with an educational institution different from that of the authors.
  5. Reviewers will provide an assessment based on the following categories:
    Accepted without revisions, accepted with minor revisions, accepted with major revisions, or rejected.
    • Accepted without revisions: This indicates that there are no suggestions for improvement; the article is accepted for publication.
    • Accepted with minor revisions: The author will receive the article along with observations and minor corrections that do not require substantial changes to the text—for example, issues related to phrasing, spelling, moderate discrepancies, or subtle adjustments.
    • Accepted with major revisions: The author will receive the article along with significant observations and corrections that necessitate substantial changes to the text. for example, revising tables and figures, rewriting a discussion section, or addressing or refining objectives, research questions, or certain concepts, among other things.
    • Rejected: The author is notified that their article has been rejected, along with the evaluation provided by each expert.
  6. In the event that one review is positive and the other negative, the article will be submitted for a third review by a new evaluator, who will be selected based on their scientific expertise and experience in the fields of education, pedagogy, curriculum, and educational innovation.
  7. For a manuscript to be approved for publication by the Editorial Board of the journal Diá-logos, at least two of the three reviews must be positive.
  8. If the article receives feedback, the author has 15 days to submit a revised version of the work to the editor.
  9. If an article receives corrections with which the author disagrees, the author must submit their feedback to the Editorial Board. The editor of Diálogos will make the final decision, taking into account the comments from both the reviewers and the author.
  10. If the reviewers request corrections during a second round, the process will be repeated. If, following this second evaluation, the reviewers again request changes, the article will be rejected for exceeding the permitted limit of revisions.

The estimated time from the initial submission of an article—including editorial review, peer review, and the author’s resolution of any identified issues—to its final publication is approximately four months.